Dear Colleagues,
We were early testers for AgERA5 as part of a European project on climate services for traditional Mediterranean food systems, and we have been using this amazing dataset since then. We are currently developing new applications based on AgERA5.
Please note that AgERA5 is essential not only for agricultural but also for any ecosystem modeling applications (e.g., biodiversity, ecosystem services, etc.). There is no alternative dataset available that compares with AgERA5.
Initially, AgERA5 may have mirrored the similar NASA climate forcing datasets for agricultural applications called AgCFSR and AgMERRA, which have served the global agricultural modelling community (i.e., AgMIP).
However, AgERA5 has a much higher spatial resolution and covers the period 1979 to present, whereas both AgCFSR and AgMERRA only cover the 1980 to 2010 period. AgERA5 also comes with a wider range of variables selected for ecosystem modeling applications.
While working as an external expert on quantitative pest risk assessment of invasive species at the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), I personally recommended the use of AgERA5 to EFSA, because most pests that threaten plant health are ectotherm organisms (e.g., insects) that require weather datasets like AgERA5 (e.g., with bias correction) for proper assessment. Plant health is considered a significant security issue in Europe because it directly impacts food security, economic stability, biodiversity, and ecosystem services. The EU has a comprehensive Plant Health Law (Regulation (EU) 2016/2031, as revised) to prevent the entry and spread of harmful organisms. Within this legal framework, EFSA routinely performs quantitative pest risk analyses that include assessing the climate suitability of the EU for harmful organisms that may enter the EU and become invasive.
In general, AgERA5 is key to any assessment and monitoring that relates to agricultural (e.g., food safety & security), environmental (e.g., biodiversity & ecosystem services), and health applications (e.g., vector-borne diseases) in Europe and worldwide.
Please consider the above elements carefully when allocating resources to AgERA5 (or similar alternative datasets, in case they are being planned/developed).
It would seem reasonable that there is at least one dataset like AgERA5 in the Climate Data Store that comes with long-term, reliable support. Especially because AgERA5 is a unique, world-leading dataset.
This seems critical for the Climate Data Store itself, which is part of the Copernicus Climate Change Service, as agriculture is the economic sector most influenced by climate, on which we all rely for our food. Further, as stated, AgERA5 also has wide applications to environmental and health problems of European and global relevance.
Kind regards,
Luigi Ponti
ENEA—Italian National Agency for New Technologies, Energy and Sustainable Economic Development